Our Menu
Our Famous Red Top Pizzas
Our Pizzas are one of a kind. Red Top Pizza By Penny’s is traditionally made in a “upside down” pizza style, sauce on top and cheese on the bottom. This is why we call it a Red Top Pizza. But if you want a pizzas with with the Pepperoni or Cheese on top, or want the sauce on the bottom? We can do that just let us know.
$14.00
Small
12 inch Pizza
$14.00
$15.00
Medium
14 inch Pizza
$15.00
$16.00
Large
16 inch Pizza
$16.00
Pizza Toppings
Add toppings to your whole pizza or half of the pizza.
Meats
Bacon | Beef Steak* | Capicola Ham | Chicken Steak | Ham | Hamburger | Pepperoni | Salami | Sausage
Veggies
Black Olives | Broccoli | Chopped Tomatoes | Green Peppers | Hot Peppers | Jalapeños | Minced Garlic | Mushrooms | Onions | Spinach | Sweet Peppers
Others
Anchovies | Shrimp* | Pineapples | Extra Sauce
Prices:
$1.15
Toppings for French Bread Pizza
$1.15
For Beef/Shrimp $1.65
$2.30
Full Toppings (Small)
$2.30
For Beef/Shrimp $3.30
$1.15
Half Toppings (Small)
$1.15
For Beef/Shrimp $1.65
$2.60
Full Toppings (Medium)
$2.60
For Beef/Shrimp $3.60
$1.30
Half Toppings (Medium)
$1.30
For Beef/Shrimp $1.80
$2.80
Full Toppings (Large)
$2.80
For Beef/Shrimp $3.80
$1.40
Half Toppings (Large)
$1.40
For Beef/Shrimp $1.90
Specialty Pizzas
S $14.00 | M $15.00 | L $16.00
Cheese On Top Pizza
Our famous sauce on the bottom and a blend of cheeses on top
S $14.00 | M $15.00 | L $16.00
S $16.10 | M $17.10 | L $18.10
White Pizza
Ricotta, a Blend of Cheese, and Garlic
S $16.10 | M $17.10 | L $18.10
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham and Pineapple
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Chicken BBQ Pizza
Chicken, a Blend of Cheeses, and BBQ Sauce
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $19.00 | M $20.00 | L $21.00
Cheese Steak Pizza
Steak, Onions, Green Peppers, and Light Sauce
S $19.00 | M $20.00 | L $21.00
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chicken, Bacon, and Ranch Dressing
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken, a Blend of Cheeses, and Buffalo Sauce
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
The Penny Burger Pizza
Relish Sauce, Hamburger, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Chicken Sriracha Ranch Pizza
Chicken, Sriracha, and Ranch Dressing
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $21.10 | M $22.10 | L $23.10
The Penny Popper Pizza
A Blend of Cheeses, Chicken Tenders, Jalapeños, Sriracha, and our Sauce
S $21.10 | M $22.10 | L $23.10
S $21.10 | M $22.10 | L $23.10
Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, Bacon, Beef Steak, Hamburger, and Sausage
S $21.10 | M $22.10 | L $23.10
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Supreme Pizza
Sausage, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Mushrooms, and Green Peppers
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Veggie Pizza
Broccoli, Spinach, Onions, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, and Black Olives
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $10.00 | L $18.00
Sicilian Pizza
A Rectangular Pizza with a Blend of Cheeses, our Sauce, Minced Garlic, and Italian Herbs & Spices *(Please note that Large Sicilian Pizzas take about 1 hr to cook and Small Sicilian Pizzas take about 30 - 45 mins to cook)
S $10.00 | L $18.00
One Size (Medium) $15.00
Gluten Free
Penny's Pizza in a Gluten Free Crust
One Size (Medium) $15.00
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
White Buffalo Pizza
Ricotta, a Blend of Cheese, Chicken, and Buffalo Sauce
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
The 180 Pizza
Our Sauce on the Bottom, layered with a Blend of Cheeses, Pepperoni, a Blend of Italian Spices, and Minced Garlic on top
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
One Size (Large) $28.00
The Penny Buster
Best of Both a Pizza & Stromboli! Boli on the bottom & a Plain Pizza on top. Choose your choice of Stromboli for the bottom & a Plain Pizza on top. (Toppings are extra)
One Size (Large) $28.00
One Size $7.00 | Two 7 Inch Halves
French Bread Pizza
It’s our famous sauce on the bottom, a blend of cheeses, and Italian spices on top of a slice of French bread cooked to perfection.
One Size $7.00 | Two 7 Inch Halves
Stromboli Toppings
Check out our all of our Stromboli Toppings.
Add some extra toppings to your Stromboli or half of the Stromboli.
All our Strombolis include your choice of Sweet or Hot Peppers, or both. (Also available on the side)
Meats
Bacon | Beef Steak* | Capicola Ham | Chicken Steak | Ham | Hamburger | Pepperoni | Salami | Sausage
Veggies
Black Olives | Broccoli | Chopped Tomatoes | Green Peppers | Hot Peppers | Jalapeños | Minced Garlic | Mushrooms | Onions | Spinach | Sweet Peppers
Others
Anchovies | Shrimp* | Pineapples | Extra Sauce
Prices:
$2.30
Full Toppings (Small)
$2.30
For Beef/Shrimp $3.30
$1.15
Half Toppings (Small)
$1.15
For Beef/Shrimp $1.65
$2.80
Full Toppings (Large)
$2.80
For Beef/Shrimp $3.80
$1.40
Half Toppings (Large)
$1.40
For Beef/Shrimp $1.90
Our Strombolis
Our awesome Strombolis come in two sizes, Small (8 Inches) and Large (14 Inches)
All our Strombolis include your choice of Sweet or Hot Peppers, or both. (Also available on the side)
Our Strombolis have more toppings than cheese.
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Italian
Ham, Capicola Ham, Salami and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
The Penny Burger
Relish Sauce, Onions, Hamburger, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $13.98 | L $15.98
Cheese Steak
Beef Steak, Onion, Sauce, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $13.98 | L $15.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Chicken Steak
Chicken Steak, Onion, Sauce, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Chicken Buffalo
Buffalo Sauce, a Blend of Cheeses, and Chicken Steak
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
BBQ Chicken
BBQ Sauce, a Blend of Cheeses, and Chicken Steak
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken Steak, Bacon, Ranch Dressing, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Pepperoni
Pepperoni, Sauce, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Ham and Cheese
Ham, Capicola Ham, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Ham and Pineapple
Ham, Diced Pineapples, and a Blend of Cheeses
S $12.98 | L $14.98
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Veggie
Sauce, a Blend of Cheeses, Broccoli, Spinach, Onions, Mushrooms, and Black Olives
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Calzones Toppings
Check our all of our Calzone Toppings.
Add some extra toppings to your Calzone.
Meats
Bacon | Beef Steak* | Capicola Ham | Chicken Steak | Ham | Hamburger | Pepperoni | Salami | Sausage
Veggies
Black Olives | Broccoli | Chopped Tomatoes | Green Peppers | Hot Peppers | Jalapeños | Minced Garlic | Mushrooms | Onions | Spinach | Sweet Peppers
Others
Anchovies | Shrimp* | Pineapples | Extra Sauce
Price:
$2.80
Extra Toppings (One Size)
$2.80
For Beef/Shrimp $3.80
Our Calzones
Our amazing Calzones come in one large size. All of Calzones includes two sides of sauce.
All of our Calzones are made with a Blend of Cheeses, Ricotta Cheeses, Parmesan Cheese, and Minced Garlic.
There is more Cheese than toppings.
$15.98
Plain
Ricotta, Parmesan, a Blend of Cheeses, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
$15.98
Ham
Ham, Capicola Ham, Ricotta, Parmesan, a Blend of Cheeses, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
$15.98
Veggie
Broccoli, Spinach, Onions, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Ricotta, Parmesan, a Blend of Cheeses, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
$15.98
Beef Steak
Beef Steak, Ricotta, Parmesan, a Blend of Cheeses, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
$15.98
Pepperoni
Pepperoni, Ricotta, Parmesan, a Blend of Cheeses, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
$15.98
Chicken Steak
Chicken Steak, Ricotta, Parmesan, Blend of Cheese, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
$15.98
Cheese Steak
Beef Steak, Onion, Green Peppers, Ricotta, Parmesan, Blend of Cheese, and Minced Garlic
$15.98
Our Sides
$6.50
Mozzarella Sticks
Five Mozzarella Sticks
$6.50
One Size | $5.00
French Fries
One Size | $5.00
$7.25
Chicken Fingers
Five pieces of Chicken Fingers
$7.25
$10.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries
Five pieces of Chicken Fingers with Fries
$10.00
$6.25
Pizza Fries
Fries with a Blend of Cheeses melted and sauce on top
$6.25
$6.00
Cheese Fries
Fries with a Blend of Cheeses melted on top
$6.00
$6.50
Cheese Fries with Bacon or Pepperoni
Fries with a Blend of Cheeses melted and topped with Bacon or Pepperoni
$6.50
$6.50
Lava Fries
Fries with a Blend of Cheeses melted and topped with Buffalo Sauce
$6.50
$8.50
Cheese Garlic Sticks
Our Cheese Garlic Sticks are made with Minced Garlic, Parmesan Cheese, a Blend of Cheeses and Italian Herbs & Spices. Includes two sides of sauce.
$8.50
$15.50
Lasagna
Our Lasagnas are layered with Ground Beef, a Blend of Cheeses, and our Sauce. All Lasagnas comes with Cheese Garlic Sticks. *(Please note that Lasagnas take about 1hr 15mins to cook.)(Available Frozen)
$15.50
$15.50
Wings
There are a dozen wings (12 wings) per order. Each order includes one side cup of blue cheese or ranch dressing with each order. With your choice of any of our Wing Flavors: Buffalo, Honey BBQ, BBQ, Sriracha, Garlic Parmesan, K-Sauce (It's a sweet & spicy Korean Wing Sauce made with Korean Red Pepper Sauce and Minced Garlic)
$15.50
$0.60
Extra Side of Sauce
Our Sauce Choices: Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Our Pizza Sauce, and any of our Wing Sauces.
$0.60
One Size | $5.50
House Salad
Lettuce, Red Cabbage, Carrots, Tomatoes. Choice of Dressings: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, and Italian.
One Size | $5.50
Vegan Pizzas
The Vegan Cheese we use contains Cashews.
S $14.00 | M $15.00 | L $16.00
Cheese On Top Pizza
Our Sauce on the bottom and Mikyoko's Vegan Mozzarella Cheese on top
S $14.00 | M $15.00 | L $16.00
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Veggie Pizza
Broccoli, Spinach, Onions, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Black Olives, Our Sauce on the bottom and Mikyoko's Vegan Mozzarella Cheese on top
S $17.80 | M $18.80 | L $19.80
Vegan Strombolis
The Vegan Cheese we use contains Cashews.
All our Strombolis include your choice of Sweet or Hot Peppers, or both. (Also available on the side)
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Veggie
Mikyoko's Vegan Mozzarella Cheese, Sauce, Broccoli, Spinach, Onions, Mushrooms, and Black Olives
S $12.98 | L $14.98
Vegan Sides
The Vegan Cheese we use contains Cashews.
Our Fried items are fried in fryer that also cooks chicken products.
$6.00
Cheese Fries
Fries with Mikyoko's Vegan Mozzarella Cheese
$6.00
$6.25
Pizza Cheese Fries
Fries with Mikyoko's Vegan Mozzarella Cheese and Sauce
$6.25
$8.50
Cheese Garlic Sticks
Mikyoko's Vegan Mozzarella Cheese, Italian Spices & Herbs, with Minced Garlic. Comes with 2 sides of sauce.
$8.50
Frozen Section
They sell out fast...
Our Take N' Bake Pizzas and Frozen Lasagnas can sell out fast. So please call to see if we have any in stock.
Did you know that...
You can pre-order some Take N' Bake Pizzas at least 24 hours a head of time and pick them up the next day we are open. (Toppings are extra)
S $9.00 | L $11.00 | Gluten Free $11.00
Take N' Bake Pizzas
Our Take N' Bake Pizzas are our frozen pizzas that you can finish cooking at home. So you can have Penny's Pizza whenever you get a craving it. (Toppings are extra)
S $9.00 | L $11.00 | Gluten Free $11.00
One Size | $15.50
Frozen Lasagnas
Our Lasagnas are layered with Ground Beef, a Blend of Cheeses, and our Sauce.
One Size | $15.50
Drinks
We offer a variety of drinks in our fridge. Check out what we have in stock when you pick up your order or just ask.
$3.00
2 Liter Sodas
We offer Pepsi and A-Treat Products
$3.00
$1.75 (20 fl oz)
Soda Bottles
We offer A-Treat Products
$1.75 (20 fl oz)
$1.00 (12 fl oz)
Soda Cans
We offer Pepsi, Coke, and A-Treat Products
$1.00 (12 fl oz)
$1.00 (16 fl oz)
Water
We offer 16 fl oz water bottles
$1.00 (16 fl oz)
$2.00 Delivery Charge
We take our last delivery order at 8PM
We deliver within a 5 mile radius from our location.
Prices & Menu items are subject to change without notice. Prices do not include tax.
® Red Top Pizza by Penny's 4/2025. All rights reserved.